User blog comment:Psychomantis108/Story: Myths of Mundus: Dark Pilgrimage - Chapter 1: Orsimer Charge/@comment-5543592-20150412104209/@comment-29458028-20150412115930

Actually, for the first one, now that I know the context ... umm, well, perhaps I know what the guy meant by the protagonist should be ultra logical. It was probably his sarcastic way of saying your protagonist was too enarmoured in faith and emotion, which in itself can seem nonsensical, due to how visceral humanity truly is. I mean, if ya pointed a gun at a real life priest, I'd say he'd shoot you without hesitation if he had a gun, no matter how much his religion tells him to be peaceful. Possibly because the character went on borderline surreal.

And what I meant, well, to put it in plain English, is to not make anyone more evil than another. It's often more interesting if the antagonist is practically a hero, except with the wrong/warped beliefs, or the protagonist is essentially a villain with his heart in the right place. It's after all the situation that decides who is a good guy, who is the bad guy, not really the people themselves.